What counts as an in-kind contribution?
An in-kind contribution is a non-cash resource supplied to a project rather than money. Arts Council England defines support in kind as materials or services provided free of charge or at a reduced rate, which can contribute to a project and demonstrate support for the work. Its guidance says such support should be needed for the project, would otherwise have to be paid for, and does not already belong to the applicant [2]. In theatre co-productions this can include rehearsal or performance space, technical staff, equipment, translation, interpretation, accommodation, transport, marketing, documentation, access services and staff expertise.
The term is narrower than everyday generosity. A working distinction is useful: cash contributions are paid into or spent by the project; donated or discounted resources may be in-kind if they meet the relevant funder and accounting tests; and resources already owned or already included in the cash budget are treated differently. A partner’s artistic work is often a core co-production contribution rather than a donation. International co-production manuals and toolkits treat clear partner responsibilities and budgets as basic architecture, not optional extras [1]. That matters because the same phrase, such as venue support or translation, may be classified differently by different funders, tax authorities and partner accounts.
Why valuation matters in international co-productions
Valuing in-kind support is not merely a fundraising exercise. It makes the true cost of a production visible, shows what each partner is bringing, supports budgeting and reporting, and creates a record if a contribution is withdrawn or disputed. It also helps partners discuss fairness. In international work, one partner may provide free space, another staff time, another hosting and travel, and another translation or surtitling. If these contributions are left out, the budget understates the real resources required and can make the partner with more visible cash appear to be carrying more than it is.
IETM’s toolkit on fairer international collaborations argues that international work involves unequal resources and power, and that fairer practice requires making those differences discussable [4]. Valuation does not by itself correct inequality. It can even distort it if high-income market rates are applied uncritically to lower-income contexts. But a transparent schedule of contributions is better than an invisible subsidy. It gives partners a shared language for negotiating what is being exchanged, what is being paid for, and what remains unpaid labour.
A practical workflow for valuing in-kind contributions
1. Define the scope before budgeting
Start with the rules that will govern the project. Public funders, tax authorities, auditors and co-production partners may use different tests for eligible in-kind support. Arts Council England’s information sheet, for example, sets out what can be included, what cannot, how to value support in kind, rules concerning time given by applicants or volunteers, and fair pay considerations [2]. Do not assume that a contribution valued for one scheme will be accepted by another. Record the funder or accounting rule being applied.
2. Agree a valuation basis
Use a basis that can be explained to a partner, funder or auditor. Common approaches are cost replacement, meaning what the project would have to pay to obtain an equivalent resource; market value, meaning the price for comparable goods or services in a defined place and period; and an actual invoice showing a discount, in which case the in-kind value is normally the reduction from the agreed price, not the full price. State the basis in the schedule. A commercial venue rate may be inappropriate if the project would never have hired the venue at that price; conversely, a nominal peppercorn rate may undervalue a genuine contribution. Disclose assumptions rather than presenting a single figure as neutral.
3. Record currencies and exchange rates
International co-productions usually involve more than one currency. Keep the original currency and the reporting currency, and record the exchange-rate source and date. If contributions are made over several months, agree whether to use the date of commitment, invoice, payment or reporting period. Do not silently update the rate later without noting the change. Where a funder specifies a rate, follow it. Where none is specified, write a single policy into the co-production agreement and apply it consistently.
4. Retain proportionate evidence
Evidence should match the value and risk of the contribution. Useful records include invoices, quotes, rate cards, hire agreements, timesheets, staff recharge calculations, translator or interpreter contracts, booking confirmations, receipts, and signed letters from the contributing partner. For donated expertise, record the agreed day rate and hours. For translation, record the scope, language pair, word count or day rate. For equipment, obtain a hire quote that states what is included, such as transport, insurance or technical support. A signed partner letter is useful, but it should not replace underlying evidence where the value is material.
5. Avoid double counting and inflation
Do not count the same resource twice. If a partner pays cash for a venue, the venue should not also appear as that partner’s in-kind contribution from the same transaction. If a supplier gives a discount, record the full price, the discount and the net payment separately, and count only the eligible discount. If a resource is shared across several productions or partners, allocate it using a documented percentage or usage record. Do not describe core artistic fees, already budgeted costs or resources belonging to the applicant as donated in-kind support merely to increase match funding.
6. Record, reconcile and report
Put the valuation into a schedule of contributions attached to the co-production agreement. Reconcile budgeted in-kind support with actual delivery at agreed intervals. Update the schedule if a contribution changes, and keep evidence with the project accounts. The Opera Europa co-production guidelines provide a useful contract framework: purpose and production details; who makes or does what; set, costumes and props; administration and rights; artistic supervision; transport; budget and payment shares; revenues; sponsoring; and future use [3]. An in-kind schedule should sit alongside those terms, not replace them.
What a schedule of contributions should record
A practical schedule can use these column headings: partner; contribution; classification, such as donated, discounted or shared; valuation basis; original currency; reporting currency and exchange rate; value; evidence held; conditions or restrictions; and the person responsible for delivery. This is an administrative tool, but it is also a fairness tool. It makes clear whether a contribution is a one-off loan, a free service, a discounted service, a staff secondment, or an artistic contribution that carries credit and decision rights.
| Contribution | Possible valuation basis | Evidence to retain |
|---|---|---|
| Rehearsal or performance space | Agreed internal recharge rate, local hire rate, or documented discount from a quoted rate | Rate card, hire agreement, invoice showing discount, partner letter |
| Technical staff and equipment | Agreed day rate or equipment hire quote | Timesheet or contract, equipment quote, delivery note |
| Translation, interpretation or surtitling | Translator’s word rate, day rate or documented staff recharge | Contract, scope of work, word count, timesheet |
| Hosting, accommodation and local transport | Actual cost, agreed rate, or published allowance where the funder permits it | Receipts, booking confirmations, host letter |
| Marketing, access or documentation services | Agency quote, internal staff rate, or documented discount | Quote, invoice, timesheet, sample deliverables |
Fairness, power and the limits of market value
Market value is not culturally or economically neutral. A rate in one city may be unaffordable in another; using a high-income benchmark can inflate one partner’s contribution or make local labour look cheap. The reverse can also happen when a well-resourced partner undervalues translation, hosting, care work or access support because those contributions are less visible in a conventional production budget. Agree rates in dialogue, state the location and date of the benchmark, and distinguish what a funder will accept as eligible match funding from what the partners want to record for transparency.
It is also important not to use in-kind language to disguise underpaid labour. If artists, technicians, translators or producers should be paid, describing unpaid work as an in-kind contribution can normalise exploitation. Funders may have fair pay rules and separate treatment for volunteer time [2]. The correct question is not only what is this resource worth, but who is bearing the cost and whether that arrangement is fair, documented and freely agreed.
Contract, tax and audit checks
In an international co-production, the agreement should identify which legal entity contracts each supplier, who insures equipment, who bears currency losses, and what happens if a promised contribution is withdrawn. Tax treatment of in-kind support varies by jurisdiction; VAT or GST, withholding tax, import duties and visa costs may all affect the real value of a contribution. These points should be verified with a local accountant or official guidance rather than inferred from another country’s funder rules. The co-production contract should also set out credit, intellectual property, future life and revenue sharing, because in-kind contributions can carry expectations that are not captured by a number alone [3].
Checklist
- Identify the funder, accounting and tax rules that will govern the valuation.
- Separate cash, donated, discounted, shared and already-budgeted resources.
- Agree a named valuation basis and rate for each contribution before work begins.
- Record original currency, reporting currency, exchange-rate source and date.
- Retain invoices, quotes, rate cards, timesheets, contracts or signed partner letters.
- Count only the eligible discount or net contribution; avoid double counting.
- Attach a schedule of contributions to the co-production agreement.
- Reconcile budgeted and actual in-kind support during and after delivery.
- Discuss fairness, visibility and unpaid labour with all partners.
- Check uncertain tax, visa or contract questions with a qualified local adviser.
Common problems
The most frequent errors are inflated notional values, missing evidence, inconsistent exchange rates, double counting and treating core artistic labour as a donation. Another problem is counting in-kind support as match funding before checking whether the scheme allows it. A useful correction is to keep two records: a full internal schedule for transparency and a narrower funder-eligible schedule for claims. Both should be reconcilable, but they need not be identical. Valuation is ultimately a conversation about resources and responsibility. Done well, it makes international co-production more legible without pretending that every contribution can be reduced to a price.
FAQ
Is an in-kind contribution the same as a discount?
A discount can create an in-kind contribution equal to the reduction from the agreed price, but only if it meets the relevant funder and accounting tests. Record the full price, the discount and the net payment separately.
Can volunteer time be counted as in-kind support?
Sometimes, but not automatically. Funders set rules on volunteer time and fair pay, so the specific scheme must be checked. Arts Council England's guidance treats time given in kind and fair pay as matters requiring separate attention.
Which exchange rate should be used?
Use the rate required by the funder or accounting rules, and record its source and date. If no rate is specified, agree a single policy in the co-production agreement and apply it consistently.
Do all partner contributions belong in an in-kind schedule?
A full internal schedule can record all contributions for transparency, but only some will be eligible as match funding. Distinguish cash, donated or discounted resources, already-budgeted resources and core co-production contributions.
What is the biggest valuation risk?
Inflated or double-counted values, unsupported estimates and inconsistent currency treatment are common risks. A documented basis, proportionate evidence and reconciliation against actual delivery reduce them.
Leave a Reply